PRIVATISATION MENACE – a threat to road safety says Prospect


PROSPECT members in the Vehicle and Operator Services Agency have warned that safety on the UK’s road network is at risk if plans to privatise some of the agency’s core frontline functions are pushed through.

Key safety functions under threat include: lorry and bus testing; training services; operator licensing administration; prosecution and legal services; traffic, vehicle and MOT enforcement administration; and routine enforcement.

The warning yesterday came after management at the agency revealed that a review of outsourcing options had identified a public private partnership as the preferred way forward.

But Prospect’s 580 members in the agency remain unconvinced over the need for a PPP and are lobbying for a full and open parliamentary debate examining the case for keeping VOSA in the public sector.

The House of Commons Transport Select Committee has echoed the fears of Prospect members in its annual report for 2006, which stated: ‘We have serious reservations about proposals to outsource any testing and enforcement responsibilities. Safety must be the top priority.’

The move is being driven by a call for efficiency savings. Yet the union estimates that one major incident avoided through increased enforcement would save £1m of delay costs, while 50 per cent of critical incidents – such as side swipes, insecure loads and tiredness – could be addressed through VOSA inspections.

VOSA section secretary Kevin Warden said: ‘The UK currently has a safety record to be proud of but we have real fears that standards will slip if this privatisation goes ahead.

‘You only have to look at the countries of origin of most of the defective HGVs entering the UK to see that those are countries where VOSA type activities have already been outsourced.

‘Our members are determined to fight to ensure that the largest and heaviest vehicles on our roads, and the roadside enforcement of those vehicles, is not undertaken by a company looking to create profit rather than VOSA’s objective of a safer environment for us all.’

Prospect negotiator Jeremy Windust said: ‘The current state of the railway system is hardly a recommendation that transport systems are better off in private hands.

‘Operators and government need to ask themselves how much they value safety in the road transport industry and how far they are prepared to go to achieve this.’

The union wants input into the public sector comparator against which any PPP proposal will be measured. A ministerial decision is expected by early summer.

Earlier this week Prospect had revealed a dramatic rise in deaths in the construction industry.

It said: ‘Latest figures reveal that 74 people have died on building sites already this year, an increase of 14 per cent on last year’s figures.

‘Tragically, it is feared that the figure for construction fatalities will rise further before March 31, the end of the recording year.’

Alan Ritchie, general secretary of UCATT, commented: ‘One death on a building site is one death too many. The lives of building workers cannot be reduced to a financial cost. The government must reverse these cuts and put extra resources into ensuring that this inherently dangerous industry is made safer.’