CONSISTENCY between fiscal and monetary policy is paramount for economic and financial stability as high debts and deficits push more countries into budget crises – the director of the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF’s) Fiscal Affairs Department told a press conference in Brussels on Wednesday.
Vitor Gaspar was speaking at the annual IMF and World Bank meetings.
Government deficits fell from 9.7% of gross domestic product in 2020 to 4.7% in 2022, but debt and deficits are expected to remain above pre-pandemic levels, Gaspar said at the launch of the IMF’s latest Fiscal Monitor.
He warned that policymakers ‘face painful trade-offs’ as the ‘global economy goes through turbulent times’, but most countries should stay the course by tightening fiscal policy further.
An earlier IMF statement declared: ‘Policymakers need steady hand as storm clouds gather over global economy.
‘One-third of the world economy will likely contract this year or next amid shrinking real incomes and rising prices.
‘The global economy continues to face steep challenges, shaped by the Russian invasion of Ukraine, a cost-of-living crisis caused by persistent and broadening inflation pressures, and the slowdown in China.
‘Our global growth forecast for this year is unchanged at 3.2 per cent, while our projection for next year is lowered to 2.7 per cent – 0.2 percentage points lower than the July forecast.
‘The 2023 slowdown will be broad-based, with countries accounting for about one-third of the global economy poised to contract this year or next.
‘The three largest economies, the United States, China, and the euro area will continue to stall.
‘Overall, this year’s shocks will re-open economic wounds that were only partially healed post-pandemic. In short, the worst is yet to come and, for many people, 2023 will feel like a recession.
‘In the United States, the tightening of monetary and financial conditions will slow growth to 1 per cent next year.
‘In China, we have lowered next year’s growth forecast to 4.4 per cent due to a weakening property sector and continued lockdowns.
‘The slowdown is most pronounced in the euro area, where the energy crisis caused by the war will continue to take a heavy toll, reducing growth to 0.5 per cent in 2023.
‘Almost everywhere, rapidly rising prices, especially of food and energy, are causing serious hardship for households, particularly for the poor.
‘Despite the economic slowdown, inflation pressures are proving broader and more persistent than anticipated.
‘Global inflation is now expected to peak at 9.5 per cent this year before decelerating to 4.1 per cent by 2024. Inflation is also broadening well beyond food and energy. Global core inflation rose from an annualised monthly rate of 4.2 per cent at end-2021 to 6.7 per cent in July for the median country.
‘Downside risks to the outlook remain elevated, while policy trade-offs to address the cost-of-living crisis have become more challenging. Among the ones highlighted in our report:
- The risk of monetary, fiscal, or financial policy miscalibration has risen sharply amid high uncertainty and growing fragilities.
- Global financial conditions could deteriorate, and the dollar strengthen further, should turmoil in financial markets erupt, pushing investors towards safe assets. This would add significantly to inflation pressures and financial fragilities in the rest of the world, especially emerging markets and developing economies.
- Inflation could, yet again, prove more persistent, especially if labour markets remain extremely tight.
- Finally, the war in Ukraine is still raging and further escalation can exacerbate the energy crisis.
‘Our latest outlook also assesses the risks around our baseline projections. We estimate that there is about a one in four probability that global growth next year could fall below the historically low level of 2 percent. If many of the risks materialise, global growth would decline to 1.1 per cent with quasi stagnant income-per-capita in 2023. According to our calculations, the likelihood of such an adverse outcome, or worse, is 10 per cent to 15 per cent.
‘Increasing price pressures remain the most immediate threat to current and future prosperity by squeezing real incomes and undermining macroeconomic stability. Central banks are now laser-focused on restoring price stability, and the pace of tightening has accelerated sharply.
‘There are risks of both under- and over-tightening. Under-tightening would further entrench inflation, erode the credibility of central banks, and de-anchor inflation expectations. As history teaches us, this would only increase the eventual cost of bringing inflation under control.
‘Over-tightening risks pushing the global economy into an unnecessarily severe recession. Financial markets may also struggle with overly rapid tightening. Yet, the costs of these policy mistakes are not symmetric. The hard-won credibility of central banks could be undermined if they misjudge yet again the stubborn persistence of inflation.
‘This would prove much more detrimental to future macroeconomic stability. Where necessary, financial policy should ensure that markets remain stable. However, central banks need to keep a steady hand with monetary policy firmly focused on taming inflation.
‘Formulating the appropriate fiscal response to the cost-of-living crisis has become a serious challenge.
‘For many emerging markets, the strength of the dollar is a major challenge. The dollar is now at its strongest since the early 2000s, although the appreciation is most pronounced against currencies of advanced economies. So far, the rise appears mostly driven by fundamental forces such as tightening US monetary policy and the energy crisis.
‘The appropriate response in most emerging and developing countries is to calibrate monetary policy to maintain price stability, while letting exchange rates adjust, conserving valuable foreign exchange reserves for when financial conditions really worsen.
‘As the global economy is headed for stormy waters, now is the time for emerging market policymakers to batten down the hatches.
‘Eligible countries with sound policies should urgently consider improving their liquidity buffers, including by requesting access to precautionary instruments from the Fund.
‘Countries should also aim to minimise the impact of future financial turmoil through a combination of preemptive macroprudential and capital flow measures, where appropriate, in line with our Integrated Policy Framework .
‘Too many low-income countries are in or near debt distress. Progress toward orderly debt restructurings through the Group of Twenty’s Common Framework for the most affected, is urgently needed to avert a wave of sovereign debt crisis. Time may soon run out.
‘The energy and food crises, coupled with extreme summer temperatures, are stark reminders of what an uncontrolled climate transition would look like.
‘Progress on climate policies, as well as on debt resolution and other targeted multilateral issues, will prove that a focused multilateralism can, indeed, achieve progress for all and succeed in overcoming geo-economic fragmentation pressures.’
